Tuesday, 1 May 2012

Artefact 4 Evaluation

Artefact 4 is the final artefact I produced.
I came up with a new story that I knew I could use my knowledge of composition to enhance.
The story is of a stolen trophy, and two school boys accused of the theft by a teacher. Each child makes his case and the teacher decides which to believe, that turns out to be the wrong kid.
I am aware now that I can't use composition to change a narrative. It's a supporting tool. With this in mind I created a single version of this story where the composition supports the narrative.
From artefact 2 and 3 I learnt that moving the camera up and down does have an effect on how a character is portrayed, but it should be used subtly. Thus I avoided extreme highs and lows and instead used the camera to represent either the children or the teacher - this would enhance the sense that the kids are underlings of the teacher, and that the teacher is in charge.
It's important that if the camera represents a character's viewpoint that it's positioned to represent their height.
The final shot of the artefact, 008, works especially well because without the character in the foreground it would only seem that the other kid is further arguing with the teacher. The inclusion of that extra character lets the viewer know that what's being argued is related to the character in the foreground. It's his expressions that suggest that he's managed to pass the blame onto the other kid. Including the characters in the background makes the viewer know it's that that he's looking smug about.
Responses show that you do get a real sense of the story thanks to the composition. The inclusion of the three emotions in the final shot is one thing that was picked up on as being effective.
Perhaps a second version would've really made it obvious what I was doing.